Hi Andrew, Russell,

On 3/30/23 17:54, Andrew Lunn wrote:

Most MAC drivers get EEE wrong. The API to the PHY is not very
obvious, which is probably why. Rework the API, pushing most of the
EEE handling into phylib core, leaving the MAC drivers to just
enable/disable support for EEE in there change_link call back, or
phylink mac_link_up callback.

MAC drivers are now expect to indicate to phylib/phylink if they
support EEE. If not, no EEE link modes are advertised. If the MAC does
support EEE, on phy_start()/phylink_start() EEE advertisement is
configured.

Thanks for doing this work, because it really is a happy mess out there. 
A few questions as I have been using mvneta as the reference for fixing 
GENET and its shortcomings.

In your new patches the decision to enable EEE is purely based upon the 
eee_active boolean and not eee_enabled && tx_lpi_enabled unlike what 
mvneta useed to do.

Russell, is there an use case for having eee_enabled while not having 
tx_lpi_enabled?

With the candidate patch attached, I have the following behavior on boot 
with no specific ethtool operation:

# ethtool --show-eee eth0
EEE Settings for eth0:
         EEE status: enabled - active
         Tx LPI: disabled
         Supported EEE link modes:  100baseT/Full
                                    1000baseT/Full
         Advertised EEE link modes:  100baseT/Full
                                     1000baseT/Full
         Link partner advertised EEE link modes:  100baseT/Full
                                                  1000baseT/Full
#

however EEE is not *really* enabled at the hardware level unless I do 
another:

# ethtool --set-eee eth0 tx-lpi on
# ethtool --show-eee eth0
EEE Settings for eth0:
         EEE status: enabled - active
         Tx LPI: 34 (us)
         Supported EEE link modes:  100baseT/Full
                                    1000baseT/Full
         Advertised EEE link modes:  100baseT/Full
                                     1000baseT/Full
         Link partner advertised EEE link modes:  100baseT/Full
                                                  1000baseT/Full

We have a global EEE enable bit which is described as "If set, the TX 
LPI policy control engine is enabled and the MAC inserts LPI_idle codes 
if the link is idle", so it would seem to me that we should require 
users to set both "eee on" and "tx-lpi on" in their ethtool command, but 
then unless we intentionally override tx_lpi_enabled in the driver upon 
probe, there will be any automagical configuration happening, and no 
power savings being realized.

Do you have any recommendations on what drivers should do? As you could 
see from the need of this patch series, we already all created our own 
little schisms of the cargo cult.

Thanks!
-- 
Florian