Re: [PATCH v2 1/2] ARM: at91/dt: describe rgmii ethernet phy connected to sama5d3xek boards

On 26/06/2014 22:01, Boris BREZILLON :

Hi Florian,

On 26/06/2014 20:15, Florian Fainelli wrote:

quoted

Hi Boris,

2014-06-26 3:13 GMT-07:00 Boris BREZILLON [off-list ref]:

quoted

Add ethernet-phy node and specify phy interrupt (connected to pin PB25).

The PHY address is not specified here because atmel have 2 different
designs
for its CPU modules: one is connecting PHYAD[0-2] pins to pull up resistors
(Embest design) and the other one is connection PHYAD0 to a pull up
resistor and PHYAD[1-2] to pull down resistors (Ronetix design).
As a result, Ronetix design will have its PHY available at address 0x1 and
Embest design at 0x7.
Let the net PHY core automatically detect the PHY address by scanning the
MDIO bus.

I though the compatible string was listed as a required property, but
it is not. The 'reg' property however is listed as required, although
the of_miodbus_register() works just fine without it, although that is
a Linux-specific implementation detail.

Indeed, it's listed in the required property list of the DT binding doc,
but the code implement auto detection if reg is missing.
However this line [1] clearly shows that specifying the reg property is
the preferred way of doing things.

I could define 2 different sama5d3xcm.dtsi (sama5d3xcm-ronetix.dtsi and
sama5d3xcm-embest.dtsi) to avoid this dirty hack,
but then we would have 2 more dtb and the user would have to determine
which CPU module he owns to choose the appropriate dtb.
If at91, arm-soc and DT maintainers agree with this approach I can
definitely propose something.

Yes Boris, I definitively prefer not to add another .dtsi file for this
series if we can avoid it.

So, I would push for this "reg-less" solution. If it is chosen, you can
add my:
Acked-by: Nicolas Ferre <redacted>

Thanks, bye.

quoted

quoted

Define board specific delays to apply to RGMII signals.

Signed-off-by: Boris BREZILLON <redacted>

Reviewed-by: Florian Fainelli <f.fainelli@gmail.com>

Thanks for your review.

Best Regards,

Boris

[1] http://lxr.free-electrons.com/source/drivers/of/of_mdio.c#L187

-- 
Nicolas Ferre