Hi Guenter,
On Nov 8, 2013, at 1:00 AM, Guenter Roeck wrote:
On Thu, Nov 07, 2013 at 09:46:26PM +0100, Sebastian Andrzej Siewior wrote:
quoted
On 07.11.13, Pantelis Antoniou wrote:
quoted
Hi Sebastian,
Hi Pantelis,
quoted
FWIW DT has been ported to x86. And is present on arm/powerpc/mips/arc and possibly
others.
Yes, I know. I am the one that did the work for CE4100, the first one
that boots with DT on x86.
quoted
So what are we talking about again? If you care about the non-DT case, why
don't you make a patch about how you could support Guenter's use case on
the x86.
I am only saying that this "hot-plug a device at a non hot-plugagle bus at
runtime" is not limited to DT but this solution is. X86 + ACPI is not
the only limitation. ARM is (forced) going to ACPI as well as far I
know. And this solution is limited to DT. This is what I am pointing
out.
I can't tell about ARM, but I am not entirely sure how ACPI support on ARM
is going to help us on powerpc.
quoted
quoted
His use case is not uncommon, believe it or not, and x86 would benefit from
something this flexible.
I *think* a more flexible solution would be something like bus_type which is
exposed via configfs. It would be attached behind a certain device/bus where
the "physical" hotplug interface is. The user would then be able to read the
configuration based on whatever information he has and could then create
devices he likes at runtime. This wouldn't depend much on the firmware that is
used but would require a little more work I think.
Quite frankly, I am interested at a solution that works and solves our problems.
I am not looking for something that is 100% perfect and may never be delivered.
+1
Fortunately, the Linux kernel was willing to adopt multiple different file
systems, and still accepts new ones on a regular basis. If a new file system
is better, it will start getting used, and old file systems are being phased out
as fewer people use them. I would hope the same should be possible with DT
overlays and possible other future solutions for the same problem, and that
we won't have to wait for the perfect solution from day 1.
Fully agreed here. I was told open source is about scratching an itch, this
is worthy of scratching.
Guenter
Regards
-- Pantelis