Re: [PATCH net-next] bonding: fix wrong port enabling in 802.3ad

On Thu, 13 Oct 2011 10:46:31 -0700
Jay Vosburgh [off-list ref] wrote:

Flavio Leitner [off-list ref] wrote:

quoted

The port shouldn't be enabled unless its current MUX
state is DISTRIBUTING which is correctly handled by
ad_mux_machine(), otherwise the packet sent can be
lost because the other end may not be ready.

The issue happens on every port initialization, but
as the ports are expected to move quickly to DISTRIBUTING,
it doesn't cause much problem.  However, it does cause
constant packet loss if the other peer has the port
configured to stay in STANDBY (i.e. SYNC set to OFF).

	This may explain another misbehavior I've been looking into: if
the bond's outgoing LACPDUs are lost (never received by the switch), but
the switch's incoming LACPDUs are received, bonding puts the port into
use, and packets to the switch are dropped by the switch.

Yeah, it could explain that as well because on my tests here,
all ports were enabled as soon as the aggregator is active.

 

quoted

Signed-off-by: Flavio Leitner <redacted>
---

The comments there suggests it was a workaround for losses
of link events, but I couldn't track the changelog as it
seems to be pretty old.  Thus, as all the link notification
stuff has been improved a lot, maybe this is not an issue
anymore.  At least, I didn't find any problem while
unplugging/plugging cables here.

	I believe this code fragment is original to the 802.3ad
submission, which would have been around 2003 or so.

	Did you check the standard for what it says should happen in
this case?  I'm guessing this is something not specified by the
standard, given the comment, but we should check to make sure.

The standard says that the port should receive when its mux state
is COLLECTING and transmitting when its mux state is DISTRIBUTING.
So, that seems to be violationing the standard because it doesn't
consider the mux state at all.  It is harmless for almost all cases
though, because ports move quickly to DISTRIBUTING or no link at
all, which disables the port.

fbl