Re: A question about MTUs and TCP stack

On 08/16/2011 11:33 AM, Pawan Singh wrote:

Hi

I am posting this question to "netdev" mailing list because I could
no longer find "linux-net" mailing list.

I find that the Linux TCP stack consumes huge amount of CPU if the
MTU of an interface is set to 2400 and it is receiving 1000 byte
Ethernet packets. On the other hand, if the MTU is set to 1500, the
CPU consumption is reduced drastically. Increased CPU usage causes
network throughput to drop considerably (from 800-900 Mbps to 200
Mbps). My kernel version is fedora core 6 and we are using 1 Gig NICs
(Intel 82546GB and Broadcom NetXtreme BCM5721):

Linux he7700-tg 2.6.22.14-72.fc6 #1 SMP Wed Nov 21 14:10:25 EST 2007
x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux

Based on my experience, you are best off using much more contemporary kernels when bringing things to the attention of the netdev list.  The list is much more concerned with current bits than those from years past.

Issues with bits from years past are probably best addressed towards the distro(s) using them, if any.

Looking into getting a oprofile profile of the behaviour, particularly if it still exists in a contemporary kernel would probably be a good idea.

Also good ideas would be checking the netstat statistics before and after a test run, and looking at packet traces.  You want to look for things like stats on collapsing buffers and packets being dropped.

rick jones

I do not know the TCP buffer management internals and how they are
affected by MTU. Is there some FAQ/information online or do I have to
open up the source code and try to identify the source of the
problem. I guess I can also try newer versions of the kernel and see
if the issue has been resolved.

-Pawan