Re: [PATCH 1/1] ipv6: corrects sended rtnetlink message

* Milan Kocian [off-list ref] 2007-09-06 23:05

I agree but ipv6 sends on device change (NETDEV_DOWN) RTM_DELLINK message.
BTW when ipv6 send LINK message on NETDEV_UNREGISTER event, why doesn't 
send message on NETDEV_REGISTER event? No symmetry ?

You should be seeing two RTM_DELLINK upon NETDEV_UNREGISTER if the
interface carried any IPv6 addresess. Once with ifi_change=~0
notifying you that the device is disappearing and once with
ifi_change=0 coming from the IPv6 protocol shutdown.

ok. However, if I understand, LINK messages handle device changes not
protocol changes. Or not ?

Yes, I personally think this behaviour is wrong but we can't remove it
unless we are sure it doesn't break anything.

Now I ignore (RTM_DELLINK && ifi_family==AF_INET6) :-). But it's only workaround
till next change. 

That's also correct, pure netdevice notification will always be sent
with the ifi_family set to AF_UNSPEC.

Hard to find it. I can try to look at other routing sw (probably most using it)
about handling with RTM_DELLINK.
Howerer when was made change from RTM_NEWLINK to RTM_DELLINK without protests,
we can try remove message :-)

I'd give the USAGI software tree a short peek, if there was a specific
reason for adding this notification in the first place, the software is
most probably found in that tree.