Re: [PATCH] powerpc: document new interrupt-array property
From: Segher Boessenkool <hidden>
Date: 2007-02-23 16:55:07
quoted
quoted
we need something like interrupt-array.Again, the "interrupt-array" helps only this one specific case, and not the general case *at all*.Yes-- The interrupt-array helps only this specific case. But the question is, will this specific case be common in the future?
I hope (and think) not. I can't predict the future though and there is an approximately 100% chance some hardware will duplicate this particular weirdness, of course.
If this is a one-off situation it doesn't warrant a new general property. However, if it becomes common enough a simpler representation will benefit developers.
Sure. But in that case, it would be a lot better to try to come up with something new that can handle the general case (or many many more cases at least).
There are developers who have a hard enough time figuring out the interrupt-map scheme, much less a logical interrupt nexus node.
Adding redundant ways of representing the interrupt mapping that only apply to minority cases doesn't help the confusion. Either educate users how to do things, come up with a more general more flexible framework, or both. Interface explosion only makes the situation _worse_. Segher