Re: [PATCH] enable RTAS /proc for PowerPC/CHRP platform

On Fri, 2006-10-20 at 08:44 +0200, Olaf Hering wrote:

On Fri, Oct 20, Sven Luther wrote:

quoted

Ben, would it make sense to add two informations to /proc/cpuinfo ?
It would be great to have a field there which will allow to check for the
kernel flavour to run, namely if the kernel/processor/whatever is running in
32bit or 64bit mode. The second field would be a generalized machine field,
or plateform or whatever, which would easily allow to differentiate between an
apple machine, a ibm chrp, a pegasos or other genesi product, etc. Without
necessarily having to maintain a huge amount of userlanf mappings from all
those different machine: fields, which all have CHRP, true, but no finer
grained informations, while we do have it in the kernel.

/proc/device-tree/{model,device_type,compatible} is enough to map
everything reliable in the installer. Dont pollute /proc/cpuinfo
further. There has already enough stuff that doesnt belong there, like
pmac-generation, 'pmac flags', 'detected as', motherboard and machine.
Oh, and bogomips...

Some powermac detection bits for older models are not actually available
via the device-tree :)

About 32bit/64bit, maybe VmallocTotal from /proc/meminfo can be used.
incredible large numer == must be a 64bit kernel
No idea how reliable it is. There are those 36bit systems, but I bet
they dont run a distro.

But why are you absolutely trying to defeat uname ?

If somebody is trying to fake it, then use the faked version !

Ben.