Re: striping of a 4 drive raid10

Started by Keld Jørn Simonsen on Jan 28, 2008

open the first message on its own page

Message details and related content
On Mon, Jan 28, 2008 at 01:32:48PM -0500, Bill Davidsen wrote:
Neil Brown wrote:
quoted
On Sunday January 27, keld@dkuug.dk wrote:
 
quoted
Hi

I have tried to make a striping raid out of my new 4 x 1 TB
SATA-2 disks. I tried raid10,f2 in several ways:

1: md0 = raid10,f2 of sda1+sdb1, md1= raid10,f2 of sdc1+sdd1, md2 = raid0
of md0+md1

2: md0 = raid0 of sda1+sdb1, md1= raid0 of sdc1+sdd1, md2 = raid01,f2
of md0+md1

3: md0 = raid10,f2 of sda1+sdb1, md1= raid10,f2 of sdc1+sdd1, chunksize 
of md0 =md1 =128 KB,  md2 = raid0 of md0+md1 chunksize = 256 KB

4: md0 = raid0 of sda1+sdb1, md1= raid0 of sdc1+sdd1, chunksize
of md0 = md1 = 128 KB, md2 = raid01,f2 of md0+md1 chunksize = 256 KB

5: md0= raid10,f4 of sda1+sdb1+sdc1+sdd1
   
Try
 6: md0 = raid10,f2 of sda1+sdb1+sdc1+sdd1

Also try raid10,o2 with a largeish chunksize (256KB is probably big
enough).
 
Looking at the issues raised, there might be some benefit from having 
the mirror chunks on the slower inner tracks of a raid10, and to read 
from the outer tracks if the drives with the data on the outer tracks 
are idle. This would appear to offer a transfer rate benefit overall.
Hmm, how do I do this? I think this is normal behaviour of a raid10,f2.
Is that so?

So you mean I should rather use f2 than o2? Or should I configure the f2
in some way?

My hdparm -t gives:

/dev/sda5:
 Timing buffered beginning disk reads:   82 MB in  1.00 seconds = 81.686 MB/sec
 Timing buffered ending    disk reads:   42 MB in  1.03 seconds = 40.625 MB/sec
 Average seek time 13.714 msec, min=4.641, max=23.921
 Average track-to-track time 28.151 msec, min=26.729, max=28.730

So, yes, there is a reason to use the faster outer tracks - and have the 
faster access time that f2 gives . How does o2 behave here? Does it read
and search on the whole disk?


As to your other comments in another mail, I could of cause install
a newer kernel and mdadm, but then I would loose the support of my
supported and paid system. And Neil said that there have been no
performance fixes for f2 since the kernel I use (2.6.12).
I thought that o2 support was included since 2.6.10 - but apparantly not
so. 

Best regards
keld
Keyboard shortcuts
hback out one level
jnext message in thread / next series-diff position
kprevious message in thread / previous series-diff position
ldrill in
Escclose help / fold thread tree
?toggle this help