Hi!

On Sat 2016-11-05 16:21:21, Henrique de Moraes Holschuh wrote:

On Fri, 04 Nov 2016, Viresh Kumar wrote:

quoted

On 04-11-16, 10:26, Pavel Machek wrote:

quoted

How would I know if it is thermal capping? There's nothing in dmesg.

I am not sure what code is responsible for doing that in case of x86, maybe
Rafael and Rui can explain it that better.

But surely it involves userspace in this case as scaling_max_freq is getting
changed.

Note that a X60 might limit the maximum frequency through ACPI when on
AC *and* its battery is not installed or not in working order.

The EC tries to detect the power brick type (65W, 90W), which often
doesn't work well on non-Lenovo power bricks, and signals the BIOS to
limit the maximum frequency if it thinks its only power source is a 65W
power brick.

This behavior would be readly visible by the X60 refusing to reach the
maximum clock frequency *at all* -- it is a static limit, only removed
when a sufficiently charged battery becomes available.

Umm. I don't think it is this -- maximum frequency is reached when
machine is cold. It does have reasonably good battery. I guess I
should also mention that it is currently running off 19V, 50.5W power
brick. [If EC can figure it out, I guess it will hate me :-)]

Anyway, this overheating thinkpad very, very likely needs a hardware
repair (on top of the kernel bug fixes ;-) ).

Ok, lets do kernel fixes, first :-).

Regardless of any kernel/userspace bugs, the X60 was engineered to not
require thermal capping on reasonable indoor environmental temperature
ranges.  If it needs the kernel to do something at all to avoid
overheating just because it has been running at full CPU power, and
ambient temperature is below 28°C, it very likely has a hardware issue
(lint on the heatsink/fan, and/or cracked thermal interface between
heatsink and processor).

Every old-style ThinkPad (like the X60) that I have ever seen
overheating when running at full CPU power (after fan lint was removed)
in a cool place (say, 26°C), stopped overheating after a heatsink reseat
and thermal compound replacement (and if you're going to do it, use
non-shelf-aged Arctic Silver 5 or something better, and "cure" it
properly -- something rather easy to do on a ThinkPad X60).

Aha, thanks, good to know. Temperature is something like 19C, so it is
not hot here, but a) I'm using it on soft surface and b) the legs are
long gone.

I was actually looking at newer thinkpad, but anything newer than X220
seems to have horrible keyboard... X220 looks reasonably nice, but
people warned me that X60s are built from better materials, and I
realize that X220 may have rowhammer bug...

So I guess X60 is going to stay a bit longer :-).

Best regards,

									Pavel
-- 
(english) http://www.livejournal.com/~pavelmachek
(cesky, pictures) http://atrey.karlin.mff.cuni.cz/~pavel/picture/horses/blog.html