Hi,

On Friday 19 July 2013 11:13 AM, Greg KH wrote:

On Fri, Jul 19, 2013 at 11:07:10AM +0530, Kishon Vijay Abraham I wrote:

quoted

quoted

quoted

quoted

quoted

+	ret = dev_set_name(&phy->dev, "%s.%d", dev_name(dev), id);

Your naming is odd, no "phy" anywhere in it?  You rely on the sender to
never send a duplicate name.id pair?  Why not create your own ids based
on the number of phys in the system, like almost all other classes and
subsystems do?

hmm.. some PHY drivers use the id they provide to perform some of their
internal operation as in [1] (This is used only if a single PHY provider
implements multiple PHYS). Probably I'll add an option like PLATFORM_DEVID_AUTO
to give the PHY drivers an option to use auto id.

[1] ->
http://archive.arm.linux.org.uk/lurker/message/20130628.134308.4a8f7668.ca.html

No, who cares about the id?  No one outside of the phy core ever should,
because you pass back the only pointer that they really do care about,
if they need to do anything with the device.  Use that, and then you can

hmm.. ok.

quoted

rip out all of the "search for a phy by a string" logic, as that's not

Actually this is needed for non-dt boot case. In the case of dt boot, we use a
phandle by which the controller can get a reference to the phy. But in the case
of non-dt boot, the controller can get a reference to the phy only by label.

I don't understand.  They registered the phy, and got back a pointer to
it.  Why can't they save it in their local structure to use it again
later if needed?  They should never have to "ask" for the device, as the

One is a *PHY provider* driver which is a driver for some PHY device. This will
use phy_create to create the phy.
The other is a *PHY consumer* driver which might be any controller driver (can
be USB/SATA/PCIE). The PHY consumer will use phy_get to get a reference to the
phy (by *phandle* in the case of dt boot and *label* in the case of non-dt boot).

device id might be unknown if there are multiple devices in the system.

I agree with you on the device id part. That need not be known to the PHY driver.

Thanks
Kishon