Re: [PATCH] fetch: when deepening, check connectivity fully

Jonathan Tan [off-list ref] writes:

quoted

+test_expect_success 'shallow fetches check connectivity without stopping at existing refs' '
+	cp -R .git server.git &&
+
+	# Normally, the connectivity check stops at ancestors of existing refs.
+	git init client &&
+	GIT_TRACE="$(pwd)/trace" git -C client fetch "$(pwd)/server.git" &&
+	grep "run_command: git rev-list" trace >rev-list-command &&
+	grep -e "--not --all" rev-list-command &&
+
+	# But it does not for a shallow fetch...
+	rm -rf client trace &&
+	git init client &&
+	GIT_TRACE="$(pwd)/trace" git -C client fetch --depth=1 "$(pwd)/server.git" &&
+	grep "run_command: git rev-list" trace >rev-list-command &&
+	! grep -e "--not --all" rev-list-command &&
+
+	# ...and when deepening.
+	rm trace &&
+	GIT_TRACE="$(pwd)/trace" git -C client fetch --unshallow "$(pwd)/server.git" &&
+	grep "run_command: git rev-list" trace >rev-list-command &&
+	! grep -e "--not --all" rev-list-command
+'

Hmph, don't we quote these in the trace output, requiring us to grep
for "'--not' '--all'" or somesuch?  

I thought so too, but this was changed in commit 1fbdab21bb ("trace:
avoid unnecessary quoting", 2018-01-16).

I do not think of a better way to do the above without a huge effort
offhand, and the approach taken by the above may be the best we
could do, but it looks like quite a brittle test that knows too much
about the current implementation.  "rev-list $new_commits --not
--all" is a so very common and useful pattern that it is not all
that implausible that we may want to come up with a new option to do
so, or more likely we may want to do that with an in-process API
without spawning an external rev-list (hence making it impossible to
observe via GIT_TRACE).

I agree. The best way to do it would probably be to intercept the fetch
response and substitute an empty packfile for the packfile returned by
the fetch, like the one-time-sed mechanism [1], but I think that it is
outside the scope of this patch.

[1] https://public-inbox.org/git/afe5d7d3f876893fdad318665805df1e056717c6.1485381677.git.jonathantanmy@google.com/