Re: What's cooking in git.git (Apr 2013, #05; Mon, 15)

On Thu, Apr 18, 2013 at 7:48 PM, Felipe Contreras
[off-list ref] wrote:

On Thu, Apr 18, 2013 at 3:06 PM, Phil Hord [off-list ref] wrote:

quoted

On Wed, Apr 17, 2013 at 2:50 PM, Felipe Contreras

quoted

quoted

Yes please. Show me one of the instances where you hit a bisect with
any of the remote-hg commits mentioned above by Thomas Rast.

I made no such claim.  In fact, I have never bisected to any
remote-hg-related commit.  I fail to see the relevance of this
qualifier, though.

Here, this is what you said:

You:

quoted

Me:

quoted

[skipping irrelevant comments]

I'm sorry, did you actually hit an issue that required to look at the
commit message to understand where the issue came from? No? Then I
won't bother with hypotheticals.

If you want to waste your time, by all means, rewrite all my commit
messages with essays that nobody will ever read. I'm not going to do
that for some hypothetical case that will never happen. I'm not going
to waste my time.

This is not a hypothetical.

If something is not hypothetical, it's real, which means it actually
happened, but then you said you never made the claim that it did. So
what is it?

My claim:

   I bisected to a commit whose commit message helped me deduce its entirety.


Your fanciful interpretation, which I denied:

  "Show me one of the instances where you hit a bisect with
  any of the remote-hg commits mentioned above by Thomas Rast."


I have never bisected to any commit related to remote-hg, and neither
did I ever claim to.  I do not know where you got such a ridiculous
qualifier as this to append to my statement.

Either it did happen, or it didn't;

It did.  Where "it" is my actual claim, that I bisected to a commit
whose commit message helped me deduce its entirety.

But also, it didn't, where "it" is your preposterous interpretation of
my interest and/or experiences with remote-hg commits.

You seem only to want to argue, Felipe.  I have neither time nor
interest in pig-wrestling, myself.

Phil