Re: VCS comparison table

On Wed, 18 Oct 2006, Jakub Narebski wrote:

Perhaps it would be nice to have "bundles" in git too. As of now
we can save arbitrary part of history in a pack, but it is binary
not textual representation.

Some of git workflow stems from old, pre-SCM Linux kernel workflow
of sending _patches_ via email.

Actually, the reason to _not_ have bundles very much stems from the fact 
that BK did have bundles, and they were pretty horrid.

It would be easy to send the exact same data as the native git protocol 
sends over ssh (or the git port) as an email encoding. We did that a few 
times with BK (there it's called "bk send" and "bk receive" to pack and 
unpack those things), and after doing it about five times, I absolutely 
refused to ever do it again. There's just no point, except to make your 
mailbox grow without bounds, and it was really annoying. 

So sending things as patches is just a lot more convenient if you want 
emails.  And if you want to sync two repos directly, I think we've gotten 
sufficiently past the old UUCP days when you want to use email as a 
packetization medium.

That said, "bundles" certainly wouldn't be _hard_ to do. And as long as 
nobody tries to send _me_ any of them, I won't mind ;)

		Linus