On 6/17/2026 11:53 AM, Jakub Kicinski wrote:

Top scores (positive):               Top scores (negative):              
   1 (   ) [768] Jakub Kicinski         1 ( +1) [91] Tariq Toukan        
   2 (   ) [376] Simon Horman           2 ( +8) [86] Wei Fang            
   3 (   ) [346] Andrew Lunn            3 ( +4) [67] Ratheesh Kannoth    
   4 (   ) [265] Paolo Abeni            4 (***) [54] javen               
   5 ( +4) [ 91] Ido Schimmel           5 ( +6) [49] Lorenzo Bianconi    
   6 (+14) [ 74] David Laight           6 (***) [48] Luiz Angelo Daros de Luca
   7 (   ) [ 62] Krzysztof Kozlowski    7 (***) [43] Simon Wunderlich    
   8 ( +2) [ 57] Aleksandr Loktionov    8 (***) [38] Chuck Lever         
   9 (+12) [ 50] Nikolay Aleksandrov    9 (+18) [38] Grzegorz Nitka      
  10 ( -4) [ 49] Willem de Bruijn      10 (***) [35] Pablo Neira Ayuso   
  11 ( +3) [ 49] Sabrina Dubroca       11 (***) [35] Markus Stockhausen  
  12 (+41) [ 47] Alexander Lobakin     12 (***) [34] Selvamani Rajagopal 
  13 (+24) [ 47] Maxime Chevallier     13 (***) [34] Jason Xing          
  14 ( -6) [ 46] David Ahern           14 ( -8) [33] Illusion Wang       
  15 (***) [ 43] Jiayuan Chen          15 (***) [30] Minxi Hou       
 
One process note on the reviewer score. Tariq tops the negative list. 
I've been returning to the question of whether it's fair since 
he has to handle submissions of most of nVidia's patches.
Still, I don't understand why reading thru the list and reviewing
one patchset from another company a day is too much to ask.

This is a difficult question. When I've covered for Tony in a similar
position, I've felt like it is hard enough to keep an eye on our own
list let alone also finding time to review other places.

A positive note here is that nVidia is now green overall, so at least
there is some participation from the company as a whole. On the other
hand, Tony isn't in the top negatives despite performing a somewhat
similar role.

I know I was lacking myself in the last cycle due to a bunch of
unrelated work and issues. I've been working to get review back into my
daily flow.