Re: [PATCH net-next 1/2] dt-bindings: dpll: Add clock ID property

From
Krzysztof Kozlowski <krzk@kernel.org>
Date
2025-08-03 11:12:49
Also in
linux-devicetree, lkml
Reply to
Ivan Vecera, 2025-07-23
On 23/07/2025 09:23, Ivan Vecera wrote:

On 23. 07. 25 8:25 dop., Krzysztof Kozlowski wrote:
quoted
On 21/07/2025 14:54, Ivan Vecera wrote:
quoted
On 21. 07. 25 11:23 dop., Krzysztof Kozlowski wrote:
quoted
On Fri, Jul 18, 2025 at 02:16:41PM +0200, Ivan Vecera wrote:
quoted
Hi Krzysztof,

...

The clock-id property name may have been poorly chosen. This ID is used by
the DPLL subsystem during the registration of a DPLL channel, along with its
channel ID. A driver that provides DPLL functionality can compute this
clock-id from any unique chip information, such as a serial number.

Currently, other drivers that implement DPLL functionality are network
drivers, and they generate the clock-id from one of their MAC addresses by
extending it to an EUI-64.

A standalone DPLL device, like the zl3073x, could use a unique property such
as its serial number, but the zl3073x does not have one. This patch-set is
motivated by the need to support such devices by allowing the DPLL device ID
to be passed via the Device Tree (DT), which is similar to how NICs without
an assigned MAC address are handled.
You use words like "unique" and MAC, thus I fail to see how one fixed
string for all boards matches this. MACs are unique. Property value set
in DTS for all devices is not.
quoted
You also need to explain who assigns this value (MACs are assigned) or
if no one, then why you cannot use random? I also do not see how this
property solves this...  One person would set it to value "1", other to
"2" but third decide to reuse "1"? How do you solve it for all projects
in the upstream?
Some background: Any DPLL driver has to use a unique number during the
DPLL device/channel registration. The number must be unique for the
device across a clock domain (e.g., a single PTP network).

NIC drivers that expose DPLL functionality usually use their MAC address
to generate such a unique ID. A standalone DPLL driver does not have
this option, as there are no NIC ports and therefore no MAC addresses.
Such a driver can use any other source for the ID (e.g., the chip's
serial number). Unfortunately, this is not the case for zl3073x-based
hardware, as its current firmware revisions do not expose information
that could be used to generate the clock ID (this may change in the
future).

There is no authority that assigns clock ID value ranges similarly to
MAC addresses (OUIs, etc.), but as mentioned above, uniqueness is
required across a single PTP network so duplicates outside this
single network are not a problem.
You did not address main concern. You will configure the same value for
all boards, so how do you solve uniqueness within PTP network?
This value differs across boards, similar to the local-mac-address. The
device tree specifies the entry, and the bootloader or system firmware
(like U-Boot) provides the actual value.
This should be clearly explained in commit msg or pull request to dtschema.

Where are patches for U-Boot? lore gives me 0 results.

Best regards,
Krzysztof
Thread (14 messages) 14 messages, 3 authors, last reply 2025-08-05
Keyboard shortcuts
hback out one level
jnext message in thread / next series-diff position
kprevious message in thread / previous series-diff position
ldrill in
Escclose help / fold thread tree
?toggle this help