On Sat, Mar 26, 2022 at 02:04:30PM +0100, Lukas Wunner wrote:

On Sat, Mar 26, 2022 at 01:49:28PM +0100, Andrew Lunn wrote:

quoted

On Sat, Mar 26, 2022 at 01:39:29PM +0100, Lukas Wunner wrote:

quoted

On Mon, Mar 21, 2022 at 02:10:27PM +0100, Andrew Lunn wrote:

quoted

There are two patterns in use at the moment:

1) The phy is attached in open() and detached in close(). There is no
   danger of the netdev disappearing at this time.

2) The PHY is attached during probe, and detached during release.

This second case is what is being used here in the USB code. This is
also a common pattern for complex devices. In probe, you get all the
components of a complex devices, stitch them together and then
register the composite device. During release, you unregister the
composite device, and then release all the components. Since this is a
natural model, i think it should work.

I've gone through all drivers and noticed that some of them use a variation
of pattern 2 which looks fishy:

On probe, they first attach the PHY, then register the netdev.
On remove, they detach the PHY, then unregister the netdev.

Is it legal to detach the PHY from a registered (potentially running)
netdev? It looks wrong to me.

I think the network stack guarantee that the close() method is called
before unregister completes. It is a common pattern to attach the PHY
in open() and detach it in close(). The stack itself should not be
using the PHY when it is down, the exception being IOCTL handlers
which people often get wrong.

But the PHY is detached from a *running* netdev *before* that netdev
is unregistered (and closed).  Is that really legal?

IMO, it reflects, more or less, the reality of devices with SFP modules.
The PHY can be physically removed from running netdev. At same time,
netdev should be registered and visible for the user, even if PHY is not
physically attached.

Regards,
Oleksij
-- 
Pengutronix e.K.                           |                             |
Steuerwalder Str. 21                       | http://www.pengutronix.de/  |
31137 Hildesheim, Germany                  | Phone: +49-5121-206917-0    |
Amtsgericht Hildesheim, HRA 2686           | Fax:   +49-5121-206917-5555 |