Re: net_timedelta() affected by settimeofday() (was: [patch 12/13] net: mac80211: Remove silly timespec dance)

On Thu, 2014-06-12 at 10:57 +0200, Thomas Gleixner wrote:

quoted

quoted

Right, but isn't that odd? Suddenly your delay measurement here might be
minutes, hours, or years if you settimeofday() between timestamping and
calculating the delta. That seems very strange to me, why would that be
the right behaviour in any way?

Indeed. clock monotonic is the appropriate one for measurements.

And that's what we had here with ktime_get_ts()? I thought so, just
making sure.
 

quoted

quoted

Now, it seems that there are only two current users of net_timedelta()
(in DCCP) so perhaps it's not too late to change some of this?

Maybe in general the skb timestamp should be based on a different clock
and only adjusted to real time when used in userspace?

You have the same problem then, just at a different place:

    ts = ktime_get();

			settimeofday()
			   offset_mono_to_real = new value;

    userts = mono_to_real(ts);

Right. I'm not really sure if that's an issue though.

But maybe that's not a real issue, as ktime_get_real() can race with
settimeofday() or NTP as well.

   ts = ktime_get_real();
				settimeofday();
   userts = ts;

So the user might see a weird timestamp for a packet, which cannot be
correlated with the user space gettimeofday().

Right, once settimeofday() is called the timestamps from before/during
it can't really be correlated any more.

This is part of the userspace API already, but might it have been better
to expose the monotonic clock, since userspace can also get at it? Not
sure.

Either way it's an issue I guess; however I'm thinking your patch is
making it worse for the measurement in this particular code (where the
userspace issue doesn't come in, it should never be accessible there)

johannes