Re: [PATCH 01/15] add Documentation/namespaces/user_namespace.txt (v3)

Quoting Andrew Morton (akpm@linux-foundation.org):

On Fri,  2 Sep 2011 19:56:26 +0000
Serge Hallyn [off-list ref] wrote:

quoted

+Note that this userid mapping for the VFS is not yet implemented, though the
+lkml and containers mailing list archives will show several previous
+prototypes.  In the end, those got hung up waiting on the concept of targeted
+capabilities to be developed, which, thanks to the insight of Eric Biederman,
+they finally did.

not-yet-implemented things worry me.  When can we expect this to
happen, and how big and ugly will it be?

Hi Andrew,

We did a proof of concept of the simplest version of this in early August
(see git://git.kernel.org/pub/scm/linux/kernel/git/ebiederm/linux-userns-devel.git)
which actually was very un-scary.  So technically we could push it at the
same time as this set, but I thought that might just be too much for
review in one cycle.  That set (Eric's) is the very simplest approach
which tags an entire filesystem with a user namespace.

We would also want to pursue the more baroque approach, where filesystems
themselves are user-namespace aware.  I did an approach like that in
2008, see
https://lists.linux-foundation.org/pipermail/containers/2008-August/012679.html
It again is very do-able without being ugly, but, importantly, user
namespaces are usable for containers without that.  For starters, we only
need /proc and /sys to be user namespace aware (since they must allow
access from multiple namespaces), and that is simple as they are not
persistent.

So I believe that this is the last scary patchset, and that user
namespaces could actually be usable by the end of the year!

I'm not seeing many (any) reviewed-by's on these patches.  I could get
down and stare at them myself, but that wouldn't be very useful.  This
work goes pretty deep and is quite security-affecting.  And network-afecting.
Can you round up some suitable people and get the reviewing and testing happening
please?

Will try.  Unfortunately I missed my chance to beg and bribe people in
person at plumbers :(

thanks,
-serge