Re: RFC: pid "ownership" of ip config information

Le 21/01/2011 10:28, Patrick Schaaf a écrit :

Dear netdev,

I want to solicit comments on a feature enhancement that occured
to me recently.

Feature:

- For "ip addr add", "ip route add", "ip rule add", and maybe "ip link
add",
   implement an option 'pid XXXXX' to specify a PID
- if that PID is not currently existing, fail the operation
- if, at a later time, that PID dies, automatically remove the
configuration,
   as if a corresponding "ip ... del" would have been given

The feature would be useful in any kind of "IP takeover" scenario.

I'm concretely working on deployment of keepalived (VRRP address
takeover) and memcachedb (address takeover after berkeley DB master
selection).

It would also apply to all kinds of routing daemons (zebra, quagga...).

In all these cases, for as long as the process is working normally,
it can trigger the relevant address withdrawal, but when the process
dies unexpectedly (oom killer or whatever), addresses are left
configured,
while a partner on another host might take them over, resulting in
actively duplicate IPs and the application breaking.

The alternative to such a feature, would be to have an additional
monitoring process, which would watch the PID somehow, and need to
be configured to know what to withdraw when it dies.

Before I go ahead and try to implement that, I would like to have
some feedback regarding the idea

- has it been discussed before?
- would it be accepted by the relevant maintainers?
- did I overlook alternative solutions to the problem?

There exists some user space clustering system that should provide the same functionalities. Did you had a look at http://www.linux-ha.org/ ?

best regards
   Patrick