On Fri, 2005-27-05 at 14:15 +0200, Thomas Graf wrote:

* jamal [ref] 2005-05-27 07:14

quoted

It would have been better, IMO, to just work on a generic idev/devinet
retrieval and setting instead of one component (as in ARP in this
case). 

I thought about adding a devinet component to allow retrieving/setting
device specific parameters (along with other settings) but dropped the
idea because I did not want to implement the data structures twice.

I think this is cleaner, it allows one request to be sent to see
the complete arp/ndisc configuration rather than sending one to
retrieve the global configuration/statistics and another one
to retrieve device specific parameters.

Nevertheless, I'm open for changes so once I've written the devinet
component to change rp_filter, forwarding, arp_filter, etc. we can
still move the device specific NDTA_PARMS to the devinet component
if we still think it would be better. For now, the neightbl component
is clean, small, well defined and probably never needs to be touched
again.

Is that acceptable for you?

I think depends on where we are going. My view is that the current
abstraction model is fine for this specific bit.

i.e from an abstraction point of view these parameters are per device
per protocol (v4/v6/etc). 

In other words, if i was to draw a model diagram it would show:
--> netdevice 
  ----> v4 addresses
  ----> v4 netdevice configuration
  ----> v6 addresses
  ----> v6 netdevice configuration

i.e the best way to do it imo, especially since you are doing this from
scratch, is to maintain that model. Your patch breaks away from this.
The only thing that is not devconfig queriable or settable at the moment
is the stats. That i can certainly see as being part of the standard
neighbor details for example. Infact this would apply elsewhere as well,
for example in the FIB where some stats are being displayed via /proc at
the moment.

We actually did discuss this a while back and i had an incomplete patch
for doing it the way i suggest above which i unfortunately cant seem to
locate at the moment. 

cheers,
jamal