On Thu, 28 Apr 2016, Josh Poimboeuf wrote:
Change livepatch to use a basic per-task consistency model. This is the
foundation which will eventually enable us to patch those ~10% of
security patches which change function or data semantics. This is the
biggest remaining piece needed to make livepatch more generally useful.
This code stems from the design proposal made by Vojtech [1] in November
2014. It's a hybrid of kGraft and kpatch: it uses kGraft's per-task
consistency and syscall barrier switching combined with kpatch's stack
trace switching. There are also a number of fallback options which make
it quite flexible.
Patches are applied on a per-task basis, when the task is deemed safe to
switch over. When a patch is enabled, livepatch enters into a
transition state where tasks are converging to the patched state.
Usually this transition state can complete in a few seconds. The same
sequence occurs when a patch is disabled, except the tasks converge from
the patched state to the unpatched state.
An interrupt handler inherits the patched state of the task it
interrupts. The same is true for forked tasks: the child inherits the
patched state of the parent.
Livepatch uses several complementary approaches to determine when it's
safe to patch tasks:
1. The first and most effective approach is stack checking of sleeping
tasks. If no affected functions are on the stack of a given task,
the task is patched. In most cases this will patch most or all of
the tasks on the first try. Otherwise it'll keep trying
periodically. This option is only available if the architecture has
reliable stacks (CONFIG_RELIABLE_STACKTRACE and
CONFIG_STACK_VALIDATION).
2. The second approach, if needed, is kernel exit switching. A
task is switched when it returns to user space from a system call, a
user space IRQ, or a signal. It's useful in the following cases:
a) Patching I/O-bound user tasks which are sleeping on an affected
function. In this case you have to send SIGSTOP and SIGCONT to
force it to exit the kernel and be patched.
b) Patching CPU-bound user tasks. If the task is highly CPU-bound
then it will get patched the next time it gets interrupted by an
IRQ.
c) Applying patches for architectures which don't yet have
CONFIG_RELIABLE_STACKTRACE. In this case you'll have to signal
most of the tasks on the system. However this isn't a complete
solution, because there's currently no way to patch kthreads
without CONFIG_RELIABLE_STACKTRACE.
Note: since idle "swapper" tasks don't ever exit the kernel, they
instead have a kpatch_patch_task() call in the idle loop which allows
s/kpatch_patch_task()/klp_patch_task()/
[...]
quoted hunk ↗ jump to hunk
--- a/Documentation/livepatch/livepatch.txt
+++ b/Documentation/livepatch/livepatch.txt
@@ -72,7 +72,8 @@ example, they add a NULL pointer or a boundary check, fix a race by adding
a missing memory barrier, or add some locking around a critical section.
Most of these changes are self contained and the function presents itself
the same way to the rest of the system. In this case, the functions might
-be updated independently one by one.
+be updated independently one by one. (This can be done by setting the
+'immediate' flag in the klp_patch struct.)
But there are more complex fixes. For example, a patch might change
ordering of locking in multiple functions at the same time. Or a patch
@@ -86,20 +87,103 @@ or no data are stored in the modified structures at the moment.
The theory about how to apply functions a safe way is rather complex.
The aim is to define a so-called consistency model. It attempts to define
conditions when the new implementation could be used so that the system
-stays consistent. The theory is not yet finished. See the discussion at
-http://thread.gmane.org/gmane.linux.kernel/1823033/focus=1828189
-
-The current consistency model is very simple. It guarantees that either
-the old or the new function is called. But various functions get redirected
-one by one without any synchronization.
-
-In other words, the current implementation _never_ modifies the behavior
-in the middle of the call. It is because it does _not_ rewrite the entire
-function in the memory. Instead, the function gets redirected at the
-very beginning. But this redirection is used immediately even when
-some other functions from the same patch have not been redirected yet.
-
-See also the section "Limitations" below.
+stays consistent.
+
+Livepatch has a consistency model which is a hybrid of kGraft and
+kpatch: it uses kGraft's per-task consistency and syscall barrier
+switching combined with kpatch's stack trace switching. There are also
+a number of fallback options which make it quite flexible.
+
+Patches are applied on a per-task basis, when the task is deemed safe to
+switch over. When a patch is enabled, livepatch enters into a
+transition state where tasks are converging to the patched state.
+Usually this transition state can complete in a few seconds. The same
+sequence occurs when a patch is disabled, except the tasks converge from
+the patched state to the unpatched state.
+
+An interrupt handler inherits the patched state of the task it
+interrupts. The same is true for forked tasks: the child inherits the
+patched state of the parent.
+
+Livepatch uses several complementary approaches to determine when it's
+safe to patch tasks:
+
+1. The first and most effective approach is stack checking of sleeping
+ tasks. If no affected functions are on the stack of a given task,
+ the task is patched. In most cases this will patch most or all of
+ the tasks on the first try. Otherwise it'll keep trying
+ periodically. This option is only available if the architecture has
+ reliable stacks (CONFIG_RELIABLE_STACKTRACE and
+ CONFIG_STACK_VALIDATION).
+
+2. The second approach, if needed, is kernel exit switching. A
+ task is switched when it returns to user space from a system call, a
+ user space IRQ, or a signal. It's useful in the following cases:
+
+ a) Patching I/O-bound user tasks which are sleeping on an affected
+ function. In this case you have to send SIGSTOP and SIGCONT to
+ force it to exit the kernel and be patched.
+ b) Patching CPU-bound user tasks. If the task is highly CPU-bound
+ then it will get patched the next time it gets interrupted by an
+ IRQ.
+ c) Applying patches for architectures which don't yet have
+ CONFIG_RELIABLE_STACKTRACE. In this case you'll have to signal
+ most of the tasks on the system. However this isn't a complete
+ solution, because there's currently no way to patch kthreads
+ without CONFIG_RELIABLE_STACKTRACE.
+
+ Note: since idle "swapper" tasks don't ever exit the kernel, they
+ instead have a kpatch_patch_task() call in the idle loop which allows
s/kpatch_patch_task()/klp_patch_task()/
Otherwise all the code that touches livepatch looks good to me. Apart from
the things mentioned in another emails.
Miroslav