Re: barriers: was: [RFC PATCH v2 17/18] livepatch: change to a per-task consistency model

From
Miroslav Benes <mbenes@suse.cz>
Date
2016-05-09 15:42:44
Also in
linux-s390, lkml
Reply to
Josh Poimboeuf, 2016-05-04
On Wed, 4 May 2016, Josh Poimboeuf wrote:
On Wed, May 04, 2016 at 04:12:05PM +0200, Petr Mladek wrote:
quoted
On Wed 2016-05-04 14:39:40, Petr Mladek wrote:
quoted
		 *
		 * Note that the task must never be migrated to the target
		 * state when being inside this ftrace handler.
		 */

We might want to move the second paragraph on top of the function.
It is a basic and important fact. It actually explains why the first
read barrier is not needed when the patch is being disabled.
I wrote the statement partly intuitively. I think that it is really
somehow important. And I am slightly in doubts if we are on the safe side.

First, why is it important that the task->patch_state is not switched
when being inside the ftrace handler?

If we are inside the handler, we are kind-of inside the called
function. And the basic idea of this consistency model is that
we must not switch a task when it is inside a patched function.
This is normally decided by the stack.

The handler is a bit special because it is called right before the
function. If it was the only patched function on the stack, it would
not matter if we choose the new or old code. Both decisions would
be safe for the moment.

The fun starts when the function calls another patched function.
The other patched function must be called consistently with
the first one. If the first function was from the patch,
the other must be from the patch as well and vice versa.

This is why we must not switch task->patch_state dangerously
when being inside the ftrace handler.

Now I am not sure if this condition is fulfilled. The ftrace handler
is called as the very first instruction of the function. Does not
it break the stack validity? Could we sleep inside the ftrace
handler? Will the patched function be detected on the stack?

Or is my brain already too far in the fantasy world?
I think this isn't a possibility.

In today's code base, this can't happen because task patch states are
only switched when sleeping or when exiting the kernel.  The ftrace
handler doesn't sleep directly.

If it were preempted, it couldn't be switched there either because we
consider preempted stacks to be unreliable.
And IIRC ftrace handlers cannot sleep and are called with preemption 
disabled as of now. The code is a bit obscure, but see 
__ftrace_ops_list_func for example. This is "main" ftrace handler that 
calls all the registered ones in case FTRACE_OPS_FL_DYNAMIC is set (which 
is always true for handlers coming from modules) and CONFIG_PREEMPT is 
on. If it is off and there is only one handler registered for a function 
dynamic trampoline is used. See commit 12cce594fa8f ("ftrace/x86: Allow 
!CONFIG_PREEMPT dynamic ops to use allocated trampolines"). I think 
Steven had a plan to implement dynamic trampolines even for 
CONFIG_PREEMPT case but he still hasn't done it. It should use RCU_TASKS 
infrastructure.

The reason for all the mess is that ftrace needs to be sure that no task 
is in the handler when the handler/trampoline is freed.

So we should be safe for now even from this side.

Miroslav
Thread (118 messages) 118 messages, 12 authors, last reply 2016-06-23
Keyboard shortcuts
hback out one level
jnext message in thread / next series-diff position
kprevious message in thread / previous series-diff position
ldrill in
Escclose help / fold thread tree
?toggle this help