Re: [PATCH] powerpc: allow PHBs anywhere in the device tree

quoted

The rtas_pci code currently restricts pci host bridges to
locations directly under the device tree root. In order to
correctly model a north bridge that has multiple PCI buses,
that restriction needs to be relaxed.

Ummm, how do you think we've managed on pSeries all this time?

I could understand this if you said you needed to represent multiple
north bridges, though that would be a rather peculiar system
topology.

Yes, although it actually already exists.

Having multiple PCI domains hanging off a single north
bridge can be represented perfectly well with the host bridges being
children of the root, because the root node represents the address
space directly accessible to the processor(s), and it is the north
bridge that implements that address space.

There are some cases where you *really* want to model the PCI bridges'
parents in the OF tree as well.

And even if it wouldn't be sane -- why would Linux refuse an OF device
tree that makes perfect sense an sich?  If some 970 OF would put the
HyperTransport node under the U4 node, should that really be a problem
for Linux?

What specifically do you want this for?

Not on a public list ;-)


Segher