quoted

The "it" that I referred to is the claim that no driver should be
touching hardware in their module init call. Andi seems to think
such drivers are worth working around with a special remap API.

Andi is wrong.

While overall it's a small percentage of the total, there are still 
quite a few drivers that do touch hardware in init functions. Sometimes 
for good reasons -- they need to do some extra probing to discover 
something that is not enumerated -- sometimes just because it's very old 
legacy code that predates the modern driver model.

The legacy drivers could be fixed, but nobody really wants to touch them 
anymore and they're impossible to test.

The drivers that probe something that is not enumerated in a standard 
way have no choice, it cannot be implemented in a different way.

So instead we're using a "firewall" the prevents these drivers from 
doing bad things by not allowing ioremap access unless opted in, and 
also do some filtering on the IO ports The device filter is still the 
primary mechanism, the ioremap filtering is just belts and suspenders 
for those odd cases.

If you want we can send an exact list, we did some analysis using a 
patched smatch tool.

-Andi