Mon, Sep 13, 2021 at 10:40:08AM -0700, Benson Leung kirjoitti:

Hi Heikki,

On Mon, Sep 13, 2021 at 04:30:08PM +0300, Heikki Krogerus wrote:

quoted

My plan is to register a separate power supply for each PDO. So for
every source PDO and every sink PDO a port has in its capabilities,
you'll have a separate power supply registered, and the same for the
partner when it's connected. With every connection there should always
be one active (online) source psy and active sink psy (if the port is
source, one of the port's source psys will be active and the partner
will have the active sink psy, or vise versa - depending on the role).

Each PDO represents a "Power Supply" so to me that approach just
makes the most sense. It will require a bit of work in kernel, however
in user space it should mean that we only have a single new attribute
file for the power supplies named "pdo" that returns a single PDO.

There's a few downsides to this approach (one psy for each pdo).

The PDOs returned by Source Capabilities and Sink Capabilities do not just
contain possible Voltage, Current, and Power combinations, but they also contain
additional information in the form of properties.

In the Fixed Supply PDO, the following bits convey information about the supply
or sink (See USB PD Spec R3.1 V1.0 Table 6-9):

* B29 - Dual-Role Power
* B28 - USB Suspend Supported
* B27 - Unconstrained Power
* B26 - USB Communications Capable
* B25 - Dual-Role Data
* B24 - Unchunked Extended Messages Supported
* B23 - EPR Mode Capable

These bits exist in every single 32-bit Fixed Supply PDO, however, 
Section 6.4.1.2.2 requires that they be appropriately set in the vSafe5V Fixed
PDO (which is required for all sources and sinks), and set to 0 in all other
PDOs in the caps.

quoted

Since all USB Providers support vSafe5V, the required vSafe5V Fixed Supply
Power Data Object is also used to convey additional information that is
returned in bits 29 through 25. All other Fixed Supply Power Data Objects
Shall set bits 29…22 to zero.

So, splitting out a particular port partner or port's PDOs into individual
power supplies runs the risk of the information above not properly being
attributed to the actual power supply.

For example, if you're connected to a 18W power supply that has a vSafe5V PDO,
and a 9V Fixed PDO, and you're operating at 18W, the 9V Fixed PDO will be Active
but the inactive vSafe5V PDO has information in those higher order bits that
remain relevant.

Just something to keep in mind.

The section 6.4.1 dictates that the Capabilities Message (source or
sink) shall always contain the vSafe5V Fixes Supply object and that
it's always the first object. Therefore we should expect it to also
represent the first source and/or sink psy under the port/partner psy.

It would probable be easiest to just expose the missing details from
those extra bits in vSafe5V object under the typec port and partner
devices by providing separate sysfs files for them if needed.

thanks,

-- 
heikki