On Mon, Sep 28, 2026 at 11:10:14AM +0800, Jinjie Ruan wrote:
在 2026/9/25 22:34, Serge E. Hallyn 写道:
quoted
Jinjie, could you reproduce your timing experiments against the
SetProc code?
Hi Serge, the test result is as below:
Thanks!
| method | Description |
| ------------- | --------------------------------------------------- |
| baseline | Per-cap syscall.AllThreadsSyscall6(PR_CAPBSET_DROP),|
| | the original gVisor implementation |
| dropbound | libcap cap.DropBound() (library API, per-thread) |
| SetProc | cap.IABGetProc() + SetVector(Bound) + SetProc() |
| SetProc-min | Minimal IAB with the read overhead removed: NewIAB()|
| | + SetVector(Bound) + SetProc() |
| mask | prctl(PR_CAPBSET_DROP_MASK, lo, hi) |
All variants uniformly drop all 41 caps (cap_last_cap = 40), and both
the success rate and dropped are verified.
Sampling scale:
- Patched guest, 8 vCPU: 2 boots × 21 runs = 42 runs/point, 1050 samples
total;
- Patched guest, 32 vCPU: 21 runs per point, 525 samples total.
Mean in µs bucketed by actual thread count (sample count in parentheses)
## 8 vCPU (42 samples per point)
method 8–15 16–31 32–63 64–95
baseline 3258.9(41) 6955.9(43) 10303.9(84) 14394.3(42)
dropbound 3356.3(41) 5048.1(43) 9914.3(84) 16837.1(42)
SetProc 3365.4(41) 6255.4(43) 10179.4(84) 16799.8(42)
SetProc-min 3485.0(41) 5603.9(43) 10533.2(84) 15146.8(42)
mask 68.2(42) 92.3(42) 224.2(84) 433.7(42)
## 32 vCPU (21 samples per point)
method 8–15 16–31 32–63 64–95
baseline 8422.4(20) 8491.8(22) 17814.2(42) 21612.6(21)
dropbound 5235.5(21) 7568.9(21) 17350.8(42) 21205.5(21)
SetProc 5540.8(21) 8159.2(21) 17920.5(42) 22168.3(21)
SetProc-min 5582.8(20) 7907.7(22) 15136.0(42) 22334.5(21)
mask 114.6(21) 181.8(21) 428.5(42) 684.7(21)
So IAB.SetProc is not an optimization. Like the gVisor baseline, it
Oh, I could be wrong, but I didn't think Andrew meant that it was
an optimization. Rather, it was correct, and possibly complicated
or fragile enough that it belongs more in userspace than kernel.
Looking forward to seeing the updated design.
issues one PR_CAPBSET_DROP per capability on every thread
(syscall.AllThreadsSyscall); averaged over multiple repeated groups, it
is on the same order of magnitude as the baseline, or even slower.
quoted
On Tue, Sep 22, 2026 at 07:10:11PM -0700, Andrew G. Morgan wrote:
quoted
The https://pkg.go.dev/kernel.org/pub/linux/libs/security/libcap/cap#IAB.SetProc
already handles this for the whole process. It can be run from main()
if you need it to happen early, and it will track down all of the
threads in the runtime.
To Serge's point, I am also curious what benefit there is from doing
it more quickly. After all, this is pretty much a one-time function
request for any executable.
FYI The "sendmail capabilities bug" reference is written up here:
https://sites.google.com/site/fullycapable/thesendmailcapabilitiesissue
Cheers
Andrew
thanks,
-serge