Re: RAID5 won't mount after reducing disks from 8 to 6

NeilBrown put forth on 2/16/2011 8:14 PM:

So your best bet it to convince xfs_repair to work with what you've got and
try to knit together as much as it can  - which may be nothing, I really
don't know.

xfs_repair won't help.  He's hosed.  If this had been a grow from 8
disks to 10 he'd be ok, as you grow mdadm first then XFS.  But as I
said, XFS has no shrink capability.  xfs_repair will just puke all over
itself if you run it.

Maybe you could ask on an XFS list somewhere.

He already did, in a way, as I'm on that list.  You're more than welcome
to ask on the XFS mailing list, but you'll get the same answer.

This really sucks and I feel for Matt.  I wish he'd have asked on either
or both lists first...

What he needs to do now is start over from scratch.  Delete the current
md device and create a new one, then create a new XFS filesystem, and
then restore his files from his backup device.

Is there a Linux mdraid best practices document somewhere, that could
help prevent folks from hosing themselves like this if they'd read it first?

-- 
Stan