K Keld Jørn Simonsen #
Message details and related content
Forgot to cc linux-raid... keld On Fri, Aug 07, 2009 at 07:34:23PM +0200, Keld Jørn Simonsen wrote:
On Fri, Aug 07, 2009 at 12:52:34PM -0400, Harold Pritchett wrote:quoted
Keld Jørn Simonsen wrote:quoted
It is a good idea to have a how-to. But there are already a few around. I wrote something like it for our wiki at http://linux-raid.osdl.org/index.php/Preventing_against_a_failing_disk but with some more advanced features, such as you do not crash if one disk fails, and you can reboot the system without a rescue disk, and you get faster mirrored raid, avoiding the slow raid 1. It does not do LVM, however, and I think that how-to should be enhanced with LVM.I guess this would depend upon the linux. Currently, I am working with Centos 5.3 and the only raid personalities available in the kernel on the DVD appear to be RAID0, RAID1, RAID5, and RAID6. With two disks this limits us to RAID0 and RAID1.I am also running centos 5.3 and raid10 is supported, and I run most of my data on it.quoted
quoted
quoted
I'm from the old school. I believe in lots of partitions. Create any additional partitions you may need. If you really want to, you can just create a single partition and put "/" in it. You still will need the "/boot" partition since you can't boot from an LVM partition.I think it is good to have a / , a /home, and possibly a /boot partition, but having more partitions is probably just shooting yourself in the foot, because you may create space problems. Those smaill partitions can easily hit some roof, like /var (when logs run full) and /tmp (doing temporary work like editing in big files), /opt and /usr/local (installing big new packages) and why should /usr and / be on different partition - that beats me.As I said, I'm from the old school originally cutting my teeth on BSD unix in the 1980's. In those days, disks were always too small. A couple of 20 MB disks (that's MB, not GB) was a LOT of space back then. By using multiple partitions you could keep a run-away from crashing the whole system when it filled up /tmp or /var.I am also from that time, starting out with UNIX V6 on RL05 with 2.5 MB on a PDP-11/45. And we had a *big* 40 MB disk in the corner. Later we ran VAX'en and BSD 4.2 - still I think it is better to keep the system things in one partition. Anyway why not describe both, and tell of pros and cons.quoted
But once again, this personal preferences. All you really need is /boot, / and some swap space.I agree with that.quoted
quoted
quoted
You can now continue to install linux normally. I usually do it twice. the first time is to get an idea of how big each partition should be and the second time is to get it right.That is cumbersome, and probably caused by your use of many partitions. It will turn some novices off.Make the default a single partition and put the multiple partition version in an appendix... In today's world of TeraByte disk drives for under $100.00 It may be the best idea to just put it all in a single file system.as sad you could decribe both. For pedagogical reasons, and because it does not matter very much, you could probebly benefit from describing the simpler version.quoted
quoted
why can't you boot from the working drive? The system should be configured to do this.quoted
4. Boot from the linux rescue CD/DVD and start the system, no network.better avoid the rescue cd by making the system bootable from both drives.'can do... I just didn't think of this...quoted
quoted
14. Wait for the mirror to sync. It may take several hoursyou can begin using the system immediately, while the raids are syncing.Good point. I knew that and just didn't say it.quoted
it would be nice if you could reference our wiki, wherever you put up your howto.I would be glad to... In fact, if we get something useful, you might want to put a copy on the wiki...to me it is very overlapping with what is already up there. For now I cannot see the benefit of two howtos with the same aim. Better consolidate it. best regards keld
-- To unsubscribe from this list: send the line "unsubscribe linux-raid" in the body of a message to majordomo@vger.kernel.org More majordomo info at http://vger.kernel.org/majordomo-info.html