On 03/10/2018 16:24, Michal Hocko wrote:

On Wed 03-10-18 15:52:24, Vitaly Kuznetsov wrote:
[...]

quoted

quoted

As David said some of the memory cannot be onlined without further steps
(e.g. when it is standby as David called it) and then I fail to see how
eBPF help in any way.

and also, we can fight till the end of days here trying to come up with
an onlining solution which would work for everyone and eBPF would move
this decision to distro level.

The point is that there is _no_ general onlining solution. This is
basically policy which belongs to the userspace.

As already stated, I guess we should then provide user space with
sufficient information to make a good decision (to implement rules).

The eBPF is basically the same idea, only the rules are formulated
differently and directly handle in the kernel. Still it might be e.e.
relevant if memory is standby memory (that's what I remember the
official s390x name), or something else.

Right now, the (udev) rules we have make assumptions based on general
system properties (s390x, HyperV ...).

-- 

Thanks,

David / dhildenb