On Wed 12-09-18 15:03:56, Gerald Schaefer wrote:
[...]

BTW, those sysfs attributes are world-readable, so anyone can trigger
the panic by simply reading them, or just run lsmem (also available for
x86 since util-linux 2.32). OK, you need a special not-memory-block-aligned
mem= parameter and DEBUG_VM for poison check, but w/o DEBUG_VM you would
still access uninitialized struct pages. This sounds very wrong, and I
think it really should be fixed.

Ohh, absolutely. Nobody is questioning that. The thing is that the
code has been likely always broken. We just haven't noticed because
those unitialized parts where zeroed previously. Now that the implicit
zeroying is gone it is just visible.

All that I am arguing is that there are many places which assume
pageblocks to be fully initialized and plugging one place that blows up
at the time is just whack a mole. We need to address this much earlier.
E.g. by allowing only full pageblocks when adding a memory range.
-- 
Michal Hocko
SUSE Labs