Hi David,
Date: 2026-11-05 20:53:21+0000
From: David Laight <redacted>
On Thu, 5 Nov 2026 12:49:59 +0100
Alejandro Colomar [off-list ref] wrote:
quoted
quoted
Personally I think that while there are issues with strlcat()
(mostly to do with its return value), and that there are often
much better (and faster - so sprintf is out) ways of getting
the same result, the deprecation really needs to propose a
sensible alternative (not inlined strlen() + strscpy()).
One alternative would be to add strscat(), with the obvious internal
strlen(3). This would be a drop-in replacement, and wouldn't have the
issues of strlcat(3) --mainly, the DoS vulnerability which is
consequence of the return value, and also the more difficult error
handling of doing '>=sizeof(...)' than '<0'--.
I've had thoughts of a more general function - but I've not tried to
write it.
int str_append(char *dest, size_t dest_sz, size_t dest_off, const char *src, size_t src_max_len);
Where dest_sz is usually sizeof(*dest) and the header can substitute that for
a constant zero.
dest_off would similarly default to strlen(dest), if -ve the function would
return that value immediately.
src_max_len would be used for an effective strnlen(src, src_max_len).
The idea would be that calls like:
char tgt[100];
len = str_append(tgt, 0, strscpy(tgt, src_1), src_2, 0);
would append src_1 and src_2 in tgt returning -ve on overflow.
(Further chaining would then work.)
But, as I said, I've not tried to write it or see what it would look like in use.
I think it's too complex for what it does. See how stpecpy() works:
char tgt[100];
char *p, *e;
e = tgt + _Countof(tgt);
p = tgt;
p = stpecpy(p, e, src_1);
p = stpecpy(p, e, src_2);
p = stpecpy(p, e, src_3);
p = stpecpy(p, e, src_4);
p = stpecpy(p, e, src_5);
...
p = stpecpy(p, e, src_9);
if (p == NULL)
goto truncated;
// 'p - tgt' is the length of the string.
// In other words, 'p' points to the '\0'.
It copies all the strings into tgt, with truncation. If any of the 5
calls resulted in truncation, it will be reported as a NULL.
You can also do the chain in a single line:
p = stpecpy(stpecpy(stpecpy(p, e, src_1), e, src_2), e, src_3);
But IMO it reads better one per line.
Then, strscpy(9) is trivially implementable as:
ssize_t
strscpy(char *dst, const char *src, size_t dsize)
{
char *p;
BUG_ON(dsize == 0);
p = stpecpy(dst, dst + dsize, src);
return p ? p - dst : -E2BIG;
}
And a hypothetical strscat() would be:
ssize_t
strscat(char *dst, const char *src, size_t dsize)
{
char *p;
BUG_ON(dsize == 0);
p = stpecpy(dst + strlen(dst), dst + dsize, src);
return p ? p - dst : -E2BIG;
}
I have been working literally years on this API, and believe it has
reached perfection. It includes some feedback I got from Doug McIlroy
about the design, which improved the usability and safety.
Have a lovely night!
Alex
David
--
<https://www.alejandro-colomar.es>