On Tuesday 21 January 2014, Alexandre Courbot wrote:
quoted
quoted
As discussed earlier in this thread I'm not sure the con_id is
suitable for labelling GPIOs. It'd be better to have a proper name
specified in DT/ACPI instead.
+1
I wonder why you guys prefer to have the name defined in the GPIO
mapping. Having the driver decide the label makes it easier to look up
which GPIO does what in debugfs, whereas nothing prevents people to
name GPIOs whatever inadequate name they want in the device DT node.
What am I overlooking here?
I should have another look at the debugfs representation, but isn't
there a global namespace that gets used for all gpios? Neither the
con_id nor the name that the driver picks would be globally unique
and stable across kernel versions, so they don't make a good user
interface.
I think what we want here is a system-wide unique identifier for
each gpio line that may get represented in debugfs, and use a new
DT mechanism to communicate that.
Arnd