Re: [PATCH] uvesafb: make scaling configurable on Nvidia cards

On Thu, 8 Oct 2015, Tomi Valkeinen wrote:

On 08/10/15 14:51, Mikulas Patocka wrote:

quoted

quoted

I have to say I don't know much about x86 video, but isn't uvesafb
supposed to be a generic driver? Adding nvidia specific features there
doesn't sound like a right way to handle this.

 Tomi

Where do you think that this functionality should be added? To Nouveau? - 
Nouveau can't be used with nVidia binary driver, and this functionality is 
useful especially with nVidia binary driver (it allows to get nice console 
with sharp fonts).

I don't know where is should be. But with a quick look I don't see any
gfx card specific features in uvesafb, and the doc clearly says it's a
generic driver. So if we add this nvidia feature there, shall we add
other features for other cards also? It's a kind of slippery road.

So how does uvesafb work with nvidia driver? uvesafb is used for initial
console, and nvidia driver takes over later when (and if) it's loaded?
And it's not possible to change the scaling via nvidia's driver?

The nvidia binary driver doesn't handle console, it only handles Xwindow. 
You can use either the VGA 80x25 text console or you can set graphics 
console with uvesafb - in both cases, the video card hardware scales the 
screen and the console font is blurry. The patch allows to turn off the 
scaling.

quoted

BTW. I don't know if this BIOS function is supported on AMD or not. Could 
someone try it? I don't have an AMD card.

Quick googling shows that 0x4f14 might be used by other gfx cards (Epia)
for something else. But I can't really say for sure. So in the minimum I
think the parameter should be renamed to "nvidia_scaling" or similar.

Someone should try the patch on AMD card and say if it can set scaling 
there.

Mikulas

 Tomi