Re: [PATCH v4 01/11] mm: add Kernel Electric-Fence infrastructure

From
Marco Elver <elver@google.com>
Date
2020-10-05 19:00:03
Also in
linux-arm-kernel, linux-mm, lkml
Reply to
Jann Horn, 2020-10-02
On Fri, 2 Oct 2020 at 20:28, Jann Horn [off-list ref] wrote:
[...]
quoted
quoted
Do you have performance numbers or a description of why you believe
that this part of kfence is exceptionally performance-sensitive? If
not, it might be a good idea to remove this optimization, at least for
the initial version of this code. (And even if the optimization is
worthwhile, it might be a better idea to go for the generic version
immediately.)
This check is very hot, it happens on every free. For every freed
object we need to understand if it belongs to KFENCE or not.
Ah, so the path you care about does not dereference __kfence_pool, it
just compares it to the supplied pointer?


First off: The way you've written is_kfence_address(), GCC 10.2 at -O3
seems to generate *utterly* *terrible* code (and the newest clang
release isn't any better); something like this:

kfree_inefficient:
  mov rax, QWORD PTR __kfence_pool[rip]
  cmp rax, rdi
  jbe .L4
.L2:
  jmp kfree_not_kfence
.L4:
  add rax, 0x200000
  cmp rax, rdi
  jbe .L2
  jmp kfree_kfence

So pointers to the left of the region and pointers to the right of the
region will take different branches, and so if you have a mix of
objects on both sides of the kfence region, you'll get tons of branch
mispredictions for no good reason. You'll want to rewrite that check
as "unlikely(ptr - base <= SIZE)" instead of "unlikely(ptr >= base &&
ptr < base + SIZE" unless you know that all the objects will be on one
side. This would also reduce the performance impact of loading
__kfence_pool from the data section, because the branch prediction can
then speculate the branch that depends on the load properly and
doesn't have to go roll back everything that happened when the object
turns out to be on the opposite side of the kfence memory region - the
latency of the load will hopefully become almost irrelevant.
Good point, implemented that. (It's "ptr - base < SIZE" I take it.)
So in x86 intel assembly (assuming that we want to ensure that we only
do a single branch on the object type), the straightforward and
non-terrible version would be:


kfree_unoptimized:
  mov rax, rdi
  sub rax, QWORD PTR __kfence_pool[rip]
  cmp rax, 0x200000
  jbe 1f
  /* non-kfence case goes here */
1:
  /* kfence case goes here */


while the version you want is:


kfree_static:
  mov rax, rdi
  sub rax, OFFSET FLAT:__kfence_pool
  cmp rax, 0x200000
  jbe 1f
  jmp kfree_not_kfence
1:
  jmp kfree_kfence


If we instead use something like

#define STATIC_VARIABLE_LOAD(variable) \
({ \
  typeof(variable) value; \
  BUILD_BUG_ON(sizeof(variable) != sizeof(unsigned long)); \
  asm( \
    ".pushsection .static_variable_users\n\t" \
    ".long "  #variable " - .\n\t" \
    ".long 123f - .\n\t" /* offset to end of constant */ \
    ".popsection\n\t" \
    "movabs $0x0123456789abcdef, %0" \
    "123:\n\t" \
    :"=r"(value) \
  ); \
  value; \
})
static __always_inline bool is_kfence_address(const void *addr)
{
  return unlikely((char*)addr - STATIC_VARIABLE_LOAD(__kfence_pool) <
KFENCE_POOL_SIZE);
}

to locate the pool (which could again be normally allocated with
alloc_pages()), we'd get code like this, which is like the previous
except that we need an extra "movabs" because x86's "sub" can only use
immediates up to 32 bits:

kfree_hotpatchable_bigreloc:
  mov rax, rdi
  movabs rdx, 0x0123456789abcdef
  sub rax, rdx
  cmp rax, 0x200000
  jbe .1f
  jmp kfree_not_kfence
1:
  jmp kfree_kfence

The arch-specific part of this could probably be packaged up pretty
nicely into a generic interface. If it actually turns out to have a
performance benefit, that is.
Something like this would certainly be nice, but we'll do the due
diligence and see if it's even worth it.
If that one extra "movabs" is actually a problem, it would
*theoretically* be possible to get rid of that by using module_alloc()
to allocate virtual memory to which offsets from kernel text are 32
bits, and using special-cased inline asm, but we probably shouldn't do
that, because as Mark pointed out, we'd then risk getting extremely
infrequent extra bugs when drivers use phys_to_virt() on allocations
that were done through kfence. Adding new, extremely infrequent and
sporadically occurring bugs to the kernel seems like the exact
opposite of the goal of KFENCE. :P

Overall my expectation would be that the MOVABS version should
probably at worst be something like one cycle slower - it adds 5
instruction bytes (and we pay 1 cycle in the frontend per 16 bytes of
instructions, I think?) and 1 backend cycle (for the MOVABS - Agner
Fog's tables seem to say that at least on Skylake, MOVABS is 1 cycle).
But that backend cycle shouldn't even be on the critical path (and it
has a wider choice of ports than e.g. a load, and I think typical
kernel code isn't exactly highly parallelizable, so we can probably
schedule on a port that would've been free otherwise?), and I think
typical kernel code should be fairly light on the backend, so with the
MOVABS version, compared to the version with __kfence_pool in the data
section, we probably overall just pay a fraction of a cycle in
execution cost? I'm not a professional performance engineer, but this
sounds to me like the MOVABS version should probably perform roughly
as well as your version.

Anyway, I guess this is all pretty vague without actually having
concrete benchmark results. :P

See <https://godbolt.org/z/Kev9dc> for examples of actual code
generation for different options of writing this check.
Thanks for the analysis!  There is also some (11 year old) prior art,
that seems to never have made it into the kernel:
https://lore.kernel.org/lkml/20090924132626.485545323@polymtl.ca/ (local)

Maybe we need to understand why that never made it.

But I think, even if we drop the static pool, a first version of
KFENCE should not depend on it.

Thanks,
-- Marco
Thread (36 messages) 36 messages, 6 authors, last reply 2020-10-12
Keyboard shortcuts
hback out one level
jnext message in thread / next series-diff position
kprevious message in thread / previous series-diff position
ldrill in
Escclose help / fold thread tree
?toggle this help