On 2016-06-21 15:17, Graham Cobb wrote:

On 21/06/16 12:51, Austin S. Hemmelgarn wrote:

quoted

The scrub design works, but the whole state file thing has some rather
irritating side effects and other implications, and developed out of
requirements that aren't present for balance (it might be nice to check
how many chunks actually got balanced after the fact, but it's not
absolutely necessary).

Actually, that would be **really** useful.  I have been experimenting
with cancelling balances after a certain time (as part of my
"balance-slowly" script).  I have got it working, just using bash
scripting, but it means my script does not know whether any work has
actually been done by the balance run which was cancelled (if no work
was done, but it timed out anyway, there is probably no point trying
again with the same timeout later!).

Additionally it would be nice if balance/scrub reports the status via
/proc in human readable manner (similar to /proc/mdstat).

-- 
With best regards,
Dmitry