Re: [ANNOUNCE] fsperf: a simple fs/block performance testing framework
From: Theodore Ts'o <tytso@mit.edu>
Date: 2017-10-09 03:43:41
Also in:
linux-btrfs, linux-ext4, linux-fsdevel, linux-xfs, lkml
On Sun, Oct 08, 2017 at 10:25:10PM -0400, Josef Bacik wrote:
Probably should have led with that shouldn't I have? There's nothing keeping me from doing it, but I didn't want to try and shoehorn in a python thing into fstests. I need python to do the sqlite and the json parsing to dump into the sqlite database.
What version of python are you using? From inspection it looks like
some variant of python 3.x (you're using print as a function w/o using
"from __future import print_function") but it's not immediately
obvious from the top-level fsperf shell script what version of python
your scripts are dependant upon.
This could potentially be a bit of a portability issue across various
distributions --- RHEL doesn't ship with Python 3.x at all, and on
Debian you need to use python3 to get python 3.x, since
/usr/bin/python still points at Python 2.7 by default. So I could see
this as a potential issue for xfstests.
I'm currently using Python 2.7 in my wrapper scripts for, among other
things, to parse xUnit XML format and create nice summaries like this:
ext4/4k: 337 tests, 6 failures, 21 skipped, 3814 seconds
Failures: generic/232 generic/233 generic/361 generic/388
generic/451 generic/459
So I'm not opposed to python, but I will note that if you are using
modules from the Python Package Index, and they are modules which are
not packaged by your distribution (so you're using pip or easy_install
to pull them off the network), it does make doing hermetic builds from
trusted sources to be a bit trickier.
If you have a secops team who wants to know the provenance of software
which get thrown in production data centers (and automated downloading
from random external sources w/o any code review makes them break out
in hives), use of PyPI adds a new wrinkle. It's not impossible to
solve, by any means, but it's something to consider.
- Ted