Hi Geert,

On Mon, Sep 01, 2025 at 11:46:34AM +0200, Geert Uytterhoeven wrote:

On Tue, 26 Aug 2025 at 13:52, Brian Masney [off-list ref] wrote:

quoted

On Tue, Aug 26, 2025 at 02:01:56PM +0300, claudiu beznea wrote:

quoted

On 8/25/25 20:05, Brian Masney wrote:

quoted

On Thu, Aug 21, 2025 at 11:03:30AM +0300, Claudiu wrote:

quoted

From: Claudiu Beznea <claudiu.beznea.uj@bp.renesas.com>
This series disables clocks that remain unused after resume.
This is necessary when the resume process is done with the help of the
bootloader, as the bootloader enables various clocks when returning from
resume.

On the RZ/G3S SoC (where this series was tested), the bootloader enables
the SDHI clocks (for all SDHI modules, of which 2 are used by Linux and
1 is unused) and the clocks for a serial IP (unused by Linux).

Testing was done on the RZ/G3S SMARC Carrier II board.

Do you think that other boards would also benefit from this change? If
so, what do you think about putting the call to register_pm_notifier()
inside an __init block in clk.c so that this same change doesn't have to
be implemented across various clk drivers?

Yes, that was my other approach I was thinking about. I wanted to see how
other people consider this version.

quoted

Alternatively, if this is board specific, could this be fixed in the
boot loader so that the clock that's not used by Linus is properly shut
down on resume?

As a result of your request I did some more investigations on my side, I can
say that, yes, in theory that could be also handled by bootloader.

I can drop this and try to do it in bootloader, if any. Please let me know
if you still consider this (or the variant that implements it in a generic
way) necessary.

Personally I would go the route of fixing this in the bootloader for
this particular platform.

If this issue affects other platforms, particularly across multiple
SoC vendors, then I think it would be worthwhile to have a discussion
about adding this functionality to the clk core.

How would the bootloader know which clocks are not used by Linux?
And why to offload this to the bootloader for resume, but not for boot?

If the bootloader is involved with resume, then I assume that it's also
involved with suspend as well? If so, could the boot loader save the
state of the 3 clocks on suspend, and set them back to that same state
on resume?

How widespread is this issue? Does it just affect this board, or is it
common across other boards?

There are some longstanding issues with clk_disable_unused that Stephen
talked about at Linux Plumbers almost two years ago [1]. We'll have to
wait to hear back from him, however I suspect he may be reluctant to
expand the scope of clk_disable_unused even further given the existing
issues.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tXYzM8yLIQA

Brian