[PATCH v4 55/58] mtd: nand: add helpers to access ->priv

Hi Boris,

On Thu, Dec 10, 2015 at 09:00:39AM +0100, Boris Brezillon wrote:

Add two helpers to access the field reserved for private controller data.
This makes it clearer what this field is reserved for and ease future
refactoring.

I agree with the refactoring part, but I'm not sure about the name. Is
it really "controller" data? That sounds like something that has 1
instance per controller. But the way this is sometimes used, we get 1
instance per NAND chip, and there may be more than one NAND chip per
controller.

So at the moment, this is more like opaque "driver data", like
dev_{get,set}_drvdata(), which doesn't really have a prescribed use --
it's up to the driver.

Notably, we already have a (sort of) 1-per-controler-instance field:
struct nand_hw_control (I notice we have both the 'controller' and
'hwcontrol' fields in nand_chip; that's pretty ugly too...). Those don't
have private data fields, but we could of course extend that if we
really want "controller" data.

Anyway, I don't feel like this question is resolved well enough to say
that we should go change all drivers to use these accessors. I know you
have bigger plans for putting more "controller" infrastructure into the
core drivers/mtd/nand/ code, so I'd like to see how that fits in here.

(If we're going to discuss this much more, I'd suggest a smaller CC
list. I'm mostly putting this here to show why I'm not taking the last
4 patches right now.)

Regards,
Brian