On Wednesday 20 February 2013 03:44 PM, Russell King - ARM Linux wrote:

On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 03:27:44PM +0530, Santosh Shilimkar wrote:

quoted

OMAP UART IP needs manual idle modes based on functional state of the
IP. Currently this is handled by the driver with function pointers
implemented in platform code.

Up until now, the nightly test builds have included a load of test code
for supporting DMA on OMAP serial - only the buggy transmit side which
we've covered the reasons earlier why this can't work properly.

We've also covered why the ripping out of the DMA code from the serial
driver, and then subsequent "cleanup" of the driver has resulted in it
being impossible to resurect receive DMA support without reverting all
those cleanups.

This patch set is yet again another nail in the coffin of any DMA support
in the serial driver; it is removing the final bits of knowledge about
how DMA support interacts with the idle support.  Arguably, the previous
cleanups already did that, but at least the hooks were still clearly
visible as separate stand-alone entities and how only they were affected
by DMA being enabled.

Actually the clean-up will remove the serial driver dependency with
idle handling. Infact DMA support need not care about idle handling
anymore.

Therefore, tonight I am dropping and discarding what I have left over
from my work on getting DMA support working with the OMAP serial driver
again from the nightly test builds and my git tree, and I intend no
further involvement with this.

Please please don't do that. We were at a point where we are unable
to use UART has just simple console with DT without the $subject
series. We can help you if some re-basing is needed for your
patches because of the $subject series.

Sorry for another series getting in between your work but this
one was unavoidable due to already broken support.

Regards,
Santosh