* Hiremath, Vaibhav [off-list ref] [121026 01:24]:

On Fri, Oct 19, 2012 at 21:30:41, Tony Lindgren wrote:

quoted

* Richard Cochran [off-list ref] [121018 23:18]:

quoted

On Fri, Oct 19, 2012 at 02:18:29AM +0530, Vaibhav Hiremath wrote:

quoted

Another important point is, this driver is also required and used for
Davinci family of devices (arch/mach/mach-davinci/).

That is really beside the point. If the code isn't ready yet, then
don't merge it.

When I asked about the beaglebone, I was given the impression that it
will be ready for v3.7-rc1.  But, as I know realize, at the current
rate, it might not even be ready for v3.8.

I don't mind waiting, but please make sure that whatever lands into a
release is really, truly working.

Indeed. This has been a problem with many of the TI patches in
general. People are working on separate product trees and then produce
patches for the mainline kernel that are poorly tested.

Tony,

It may not be true always, as we always work simultaneously and there are 
high chances that some patches/development is dependent on others from 
functionality perspective (especially baseport), but still they are 
independent modules (may be for other devices).

Lets take a example of AM33xx and OMAP5 here, we started submitting baseport 
patches to the list (almost 6-8 months now), not all the patches gets 
accepted together in one shot.
As you know, when we started pushing AM33xx and OMAP5 baseport patches, we 
were at the stage where both DT and hwmod was required. First attempt for 
board file submission did not went through, since we decided to force all 
new devices migrate to DT, right?

I think you guys have done a pretty good job with the am33xx patches
in general to get the core omap changes merged.
 

So the criteria initially was, build should not break and submit patches 
step-by-step.

Now, with baseport patches submitted to list, individual developer can also 
start submitting patches to the respective driver's list, making sure that, 
driver doesn't change irrespective of platform. I do not see anything wrong
with this, as we always consider driver independent.

In this particular case, note that, all the patches Richard posted recently 
are AM33xx SoC integration specific patches only.

Yes now the core omap patches are merged, and people want to use
the devices with mainline kernel. That's usually good news :)

Regards,

Tony