On Wed, Jun 20, 2012 at 02:44:50PM +0100, Lee Jones wrote:

quoted

Shouldn't this be in the platform IRQ handler, rather than the core v7 perf
code?

Well that's where it currently resides, but in the process of DT:ing the 
platform, we have no real way to set the call-back. Normally, if it's 
absolutely necessary, we do this with AUXDATA. However in the PMU case 
we fall-down as a device address is required for DT look-up, which the 
PMU does not have.

Right, so I suspect this is going to be a huge problem for the OMAP guys,
where they have to do a fair amount of jiggery-pokery to kick their PMU into
action. We are also looking to put suspend/resume hooks into the
arm_pmu_platdata which will undoubtedly be highly platform-specific.

I spoke with Arnd about sensible solutions and he suggested placing the 
logic inside the generic instead, thus supporting muxed IRQ lines 
without the requirement of providing a platform specific handler in 
every instance this occurs (although, I think the ux500 are the only 
platform to do this currently).

Whilst this code isn't too problematic (but yes, you are the only platform
that needs it) I think if we solve the bigger problem then you can use the
same solution to do your IRQ ping-ponging.

I'd be happy to take any other suggestions, but this seemed fairly neat 
and unobtrusive (not withstanding the predicate cock-up).

Can we not fix the AUXDATA stuff to assume address 0 if it's not present for
the matching node? This will work for perf as I don't expect to have
multiple nodes with the same compatible string for PMUs that are not
memory-mapped (for big.LITTLE, the strings will be different).

Will