On Sun, Jan 02, 2011 at 09:33:34PM +0100, Linus Walleij wrote:

As for the in-tree PL08x driver I'd say it's doing pretty well for
memcpy() so we could add platform data for that on supported
platforms, then for device transfers we need more elaborative
work.

It has the issue that it's not unmapping the buffers after the memcpy()
operation has completed, so on ARMv6+ we have the possibility for
speculative prefetches to corrupt the destination buffer.

Neither are a number of the other DMA engine drivers.  This is why I'd
like to see some common infrastructure in the DMA engine core for saying
"this tx descriptor is now complete" so that DMA engine driver authors
don't have to even think about whether they should be unmapping buffers.

I'd also like to see DMA_COMPL_SKIP_*_UNMAP always set by prep_slave_sg()
in tx->flags so we don't have to end up with "is this a slave operation"
tests in the completion handler.