Re: [rfc] increase struct page size?!

On Sunday 20 May 2007 06:10:16 Eric Dumazet wrote:

Christoph Lameter a écrit :

quoted

On Sat, 19 May 2007, William Lee Irwin III wrote:

quoted

However, there are numerous optimizations and features made possible
with flag bits, which might as could be made cheap by padding struct
page up to the next highest power of 2 bytes with space for flag bits.

Well the last time I tried to get this by Andi we became a bit concerned 
when we realized that the memory map would grow by 14% in size. Given 
that 4k page size challenged platforms have a huge amount of page structs 
that growth is significant. I think it would be fine to do it for IA64 
with 16k page size but not for x86_64.

This reminds me Andi attempted in the past to convert 'flags' to a 32 bits field :

http://marc.info/?l=linux-kernel&m=107903527523739&w=2

I wonder why this idea was not taken, saving 2MB per GB of memory is nice :)

It made sense in 2.4, but in 2.6 it doesn't actually save any memory because
there is no field to put into the freed padding.

Besides with the scarcity of pageflags it might make sense to do "64 bit only"
flags at some point.

-Andi