Re: [PATCH RFC] mm: add MAP_EXCLUSIVE to create exclusive user mappings

From
Tycho Andersen <hidden>
Date
2019-10-29 15:13:49
Also in
linux-mm, lkml
Reply to
Reshetova, Elena, 2019-10-29
Hi Elena, Mike,

On Tue, Oct 29, 2019 at 11:25:12AM +0000, Reshetova, Elena wrote:
quoted
The patch below aims to allow applications to create mappins that have
pages visible only to the owning process. Such mappings could be used to
store secrets so that these secrets are not visible neither to other
processes nor to the kernel.
Hi Mike, 

I have actually been looking into the closely related problem for the past 
couple of weeks (on and off). What is common here is the need for userspace
to indicate to kernel that some pages contain secrets. And then there are
actually a number of things that kernel can do to try to protect these secrets
better. Unmap from direct map is one of them. Another thing is to map such
pages as non-cached, which can help us to prevent or considerably restrict
speculation on such pages. The initial proof of concept for marking pages as
"UNCACHED" that I got from Dave Hansen was actually based on mlock2() 
and a new flag for it for this purpose. Since then I have been thinking on what
interface suits the use case better and actually selected going with new madvise() 
flag instead because of all possible implications for fragmentation and performance. 
My logic was that we better allocate the secret data explicitly (using mmap()) 
to make sure that no other process data accidentally gets to suffer.
Imagine I would allocate a buffer to hold a secret key, signal with mlock
 to protect it and suddenly my other high throughput non-secret buffer 
(which happened to live on the same page by chance) became very slow
 and I don't even have an easy way (apart from mmap()ing it!) to guarantee
 that it won't be affected.

So, I ended up towards smth like:

  secret_buffer =  mmap(NULL, PAGE_SIZE, ...)
   madvise(secret_buffer, size, MADV_SECRET)

I have work in progress code here:
 https://github.com/ereshetova/linux/commits/madvise

I haven't sent it for review, because it is not ready yet and I am now working
on trying to add the page wiping functionality. Otherwise it would be useless
to protect the page during the time it is used in userspace, but then allow it
to get reused by a different process later after it has been released back and
userspace was stupid enough not to wipe the contents (or was crashed on 
purpose before it was able to wipe anything out). 
I was looking at this and thinking that wiping during do_exit() might
be a nice place, but I haven't tried anything yet.
We have also had some discussions with Tycho that XPFO can be also
applied selectively for such "SECRET" marked pages and I know that he has also
did some initial prototyping on this, so I think it would be great to decide
on userspace interface first and then see how we can assemble together all
these features. 
Yep! Here's my tree with the direct un-mapping bits ported from XPFO:
https://github.com/tych0/linux/commits/madvise

As noted in one of the commit messages I think the bit math for page
prot flags needs a bit of work, but the test passes, so :)

In any case, I'll try to look at Mike's patches later today.

Cheers,

Tycho
Thread (56 messages) 56 messages, 20 authors, last reply 2019-12-08
Keyboard shortcuts
hback out one level
jnext message in thread / next series-diff position
kprevious message in thread / previous series-diff position
ldrill in
Escclose help / fold thread tree
?toggle this help