Jann Horn [off-list ref] wrote:

It might make sense to require that the path points to the root inode
of the superblock? That way you wouldn't be able to do this on a bind
mount that exposes part of a shared filesystem to a container.

Why prevent that?  It doesn't prevent the container denizen from watching a
bind mount that exposes the root of a shared filesystem into a container.

It probably makes sense to permit the LSM to rule on whether a watch may be
emplaced, however.

quoted

+                       ret = add_watch_to_object(watch, s->s_watchers);
+                       if (ret == 0) {
+                               spin_lock(&sb_lock);
+                               s->s_count++;
+                               spin_unlock(&sb_lock);

Why do watches hold references on the superblock they're watching?

Fair point.  It was necessary at one point, but I don't think it is now.  I'll
see if I can remove it.  Note that it doesn't stop a superblock from being
unmounted and destroyed.

quoted

+                       }
+               }
+               up_write(&s->s_umount);
+               if (ret < 0)
+                       kfree(watch);
+       } else if (s->s_watchers) {

This should probably have something like a READ_ONCE() for clarity?

Note that I think I'll rearrange this to:

	} else {
		ret = -EBADSLT;
		if (s->s_watchers) {
			down_write(&s->s_umount);
			ret = remove_watch_from_object(s->s_watchers, wqueue,
						       s->s_unique_id, false);
			up_write(&s->s_umount);
		}
	}

I'm not sure READ_ONCE() is necessary, since s_watchers can only be
instantiated once and the watch list then persists until the superblock is
deactivated.  Furthermore, by the time deactivate_locked_super() is called, we
can't be calling sb_notify() on it as it's become inaccessible.

So if we see s->s_watchers as non-NULL, we should not see anything different
inside the lock.  In fact, I should be able to rewrite the above to:

	} else {
		ret = -EBADSLT;
		wlist = s->s_watchers;
		if (wlist) {
			down_write(&s->s_umount);
			ret = remove_watch_from_object(wlist, wqueue,
						       s->s_unique_id, false);
			up_write(&s->s_umount);
		}
	}

David