Re: [PATCH 1/1] Userspace I/O (UIO): Add support for userspace DMA (corrected)

On Thu, Dec 11, 2008 at 01:33:41AM +0100, Hans J. Koch wrote:

On Wed, Dec 03, 2008 at 05:51:30PM -0800, Edward Estabrook wrote:

quoted

From: Edward Estabrook <redacted>

Here is a patch that adds the ability to dynamically allocate and use
coherent DMA
from userspace by extending the Userspace IO driver.  This patch applies against
2.6.28-rc6.

Hi Edward,
sorry I didn't answer sooner. It was not lack of interest in your work, I
just had to think about it (and had quite a lot of other work, too).
I consider your idea of having DMA coherent memory allocatable from userspace
a valid demand. However, the interface should be implemented differently.

As a general requirement, all information you need to pass to userspace has
to go through sysfs. This is a UIO design decision and should not be changed
lightly. Please don't fill information into the allocated memory.

We shouldn't mix dynamically allocated DMA regions with the already existing
static memory mappings. There should be an extra directory, maybe called
/sys/class/uio/uioN/dyn_dma_mem/ containing information about this kind of
DMA memory. This directory would not exist by default, it's only created if
some user actually allocates such memory.

In the UIO core, these mappings should be handled with a dynamic list, not
a static array. The number of possible mappings has to be limited to a
sensible maximum, maybe 50 or 100. The code handling the existing static
mappings could mostly stay as-is.

I like that idea of a seperate directory in sysfs. How about allocating
DMA memory by creating files in this directory. The memory itself can be
accessed via mmap() and the dma address can be gathered using read().
When a file is closed the dma memory is unmapped.
This would work great as long as /sys/class/uio/uioN/ belongs only to
one physical device.

Joerg