On Tue, Jan 28, 2025 at 7:02 PM Casey Schaufler [off-list ref] wrote:
I can't say I agree that it's an access control because although it is
specific to a process it isn't specific to an object. You can still access
the set of objects using other means. It is a mechanism control, preventing
use of io_uring entirely.
I see your argument and raise you "capabilities".
Granted, we could have a fairly lively debate about the merits of
capabilities, which I'm not encouraging here, I'm only mentioning it
as a counterpoint and evidence that there is precedent for things like
this as "access control".
I'm much more concerned about bugs in io_uring than in xyzzy. The io_uring
people have been pretty good about addressing LSM issues, so it's not
a huge deal, but I never like seeing switches to turn off features because
security is active.
If no one else shares my concern you can put my comments down to the
ravings of the lunatic fringe and ignore them.
Fair enough. FWIW, I appreciate the discussion, even if we didn't
quite reach consensus this time around.
--
paul-moore.com