Re: [PATCH] git-sparse-checkout: clarify interactions with submodules
From: Derrick Stolee <hidden>
Date: 2020-06-11 11:32:50
On 6/10/2020 7:16 PM, Elijah Newren via GitGitGadget wrote:
+If your repository contains one or more submodules, then submodules +are populated based on interactions with the `git submodule` command. +Specifically, `git submodule init -- <path>` will ensure the submodule +at `<path>` is present, while `git submodule deinit [-f] -- <path>` +will remove the files for the submodule at `<path>` (including any +untracked files, uncommitted changes, and unpushed history). Similar +to how sparse-checkout removes files from the working tree but still +leaves entries in the index, deinitialized submodules are removed from +the working directory but still have an entry in the index. + +Since submodules may have unpushed changes or untracked files, +removing them could result in data loss. Thus, changing sparse +inclusion/exclusion rules will not cause an already checked out +submodule to be removed from the working copy. Said another way, just +as `checkout` will not cause submodules to be automatically removed or +initialized even when switching between branches that remove or add +submodules, using `sparse-checkout` to reduce or expand the scope of +"interesting" files will not cause submodules to be automatically +deinitialized or initialized either. + +Further, the above facts mean that there are multiple reasons that +"tracked" files might not be present in the working copy: sparsity +pattern application from sparse-checkout, and submodule initialization +state. Thus, commands like `git grep` that work on tracked files in +the working copy may return results that are limited by either or both +of these restrictions.
This new version looks great. I have nothing to add. -Stolee