Thread (9 messages) flat view 9 messages, 7 authors, 2016-08-11

Questions about the new

From: Sergio <hidden>
Date: 2016-08-11 17:46:01



Hi,

I read from the release notes of git 1.6.5 about the new "replace" mechanism.
It is presented as "a replacement of the "grafts" mechanism, with the added
advantage that it can be transferred across repositories."

Since there is still little information about it, I would like to ask the
following:

1) Grafts and replace entries seem to operate on different aspects of the
history graph. Grafts operate on arcs and replace on nodes. 
As such, replace entries seem less general to me. 
Apparently, to simulate a graft with replace entries, you need to introduce
extra commit objects. For instance, if object B has no parents, to pretend that
it derives from some A, one needs to create an object B' equivalent to B but
for the parents and then replace B by B', is this right? Conversely, I guess
you can always simulate a replace entry with the graft mechanism, without the
need to add any extra commit object. Am I overlooking something? 

2) Is it currently possible to use a replace entry to replace a commit object
with nothing? Namely if B has A as its sole parent, is it possible to have a
replace entry such as A-sha1 becomes null, to pretend that B is a hierarchy
root?  

3) If I remember correctly, there was a reason why grafts were not considered
suitable for transferring across repos. Can someone remind me about it? How
does the replace mechanism address this issue?

Thanks,

Sergio
Keyboard shortcuts
hback out one level
jnext message in thread
kprevious message in thread
ldrill in
Escclose help / fold thread tree
?toggle this help